The 5 Best Sushi Restaurants in NYC — According to 5 Reasons to Visit Readers

Nov 7

These Are the Best Sushi Restaurants in NYC According to 5 Reasons to Visit Readers

When it comes to sushi, New York City is at the pinnacle of perfection. The city offers some of the most authentic and innovative sushi experiences outside of Japan. According to 5 Reasons to Visit readers, these top 5 sushi spots are NYC’s absolute best, delivering the freshest fish, expertly crafted dishes, and unforgettable ambiance. Each of these restaurants offers a unique approach to sushi that goes beyond mere dining—it’s an experience that connects you to the art and tradition of Japanese cuisine.

Whether you’re a sushi aficionado or a curious first-timer, these mouthwatering NYC sushi spots are not to be missed. Here’s what makes each of them a must-visit.

1. Sushi Nakazawa – West Village

Sushi Nakazawa is a Michelin-starred favorite for sushi enthusiasts seeking the artistry of omakase. With Chef Daisuke Nakazawa, a protégé of Japan's Jiro Ono, the 20-course tasting menu highlights melt-in-your-mouth cuts of fresh fish, served in a minimalist yet elegant setting.

Readers rave about the attentive service and Chef Nakazawa’s careful attention to flavor combinations, making it perfect for special occasions.

2. Masa – Columbus Circle

Located inside the Time Warner Center, Masa offers an ultra-luxurious experience that’s worth every penny. Chef Masa Takayama serves an ever-changing omakase menu with a focus on pure, high-quality ingredients flown in from Japan.

Readers love Masa’s intimate setting, limited seating, and sublime presentation, describing it as the epitome of “sushi artistry.”

3. Kura – East Village

For those looking for an authentic Tokyo-style experience without breaking the bank, Kura is an unassuming East Village gem. Offering a relaxed yet traditional omakase experience, Kura’s chefs bring out the flavors of each fish using minimal ingredients and attention to texture.

Readers adore the laid-back, no-fuss vibe that lets the sushi speak for itself.

4. Shuko – Union Square

At Shuko, sushi is redefined with a unique New York twist. The tasting menu mixes sushi and Japanese-inspired small plates, often combining unexpected ingredients that work in perfect harmony. Shuko's creativity and energy make it ideal for adventurous foodies.

Readers appreciate the interactive experience with the chefs, who bring a fresh perspective to classic Japanese flavors.

5. Sushi Yasuda – Midtown East

Sushi Yasuda is a Midtown institution, praised for its classic approach and devotion to purity in taste. Each piece of fish is delicately seasoned without dipping sauces, letting the quality shine.