Lake Placid Gets the Olympics. Saranac Lake Gets the Locals. Here’s Which One to Pick.
5 Reasons to Visit® · New York · Adirondacks
Lake Placid Gets the Olympics. Saranac Lake Gets the Locals. Here’s Which One to Pick.
Ten miles of Adirondack forest separate two villages with completely different personalities: one built on Olympic glory, the other on art, history and a lake-town calm. Here’s how they stack up, round by round.
Advertisement
Lake Placid
Saranac LakeLake Placid and Saranac Lake sit about ten miles apart in New York’s Adirondack Park, close enough to share a weather report and different enough to shape an entire trip. Lake Placid, twice host of the Winter Olympics, is the region’s marquee name, with a busy Main Street, world-class ski slopes and Olympic venues you can actually ride. Saranac Lake, a former health-resort village turned arts town, is smaller, quieter and more local, wrapped around a chain of lakes and famous for a winter carnival with a palace made of ice. Now that the Adirondack Rail Trail links them by bike and on foot, the real question is where to sleep. We compared them across five rounds.
Advertisement
1Things to See & Do
Things to Do: Olympic Thrills vs. Small-Town History
Lake Placid
Lake Placid hosted the Winter Olympics in 1932 and 1980, and the venues are still open for business. Skate where the “Miracle on Ice” happened at the Olympic Center’s 1980 Herb Brooks Arena, tour one of North America’s largest collections of Winter Olympic artifacts at the Lake Placid Olympic Museum, ride to the top of the Olympic Jumping Complex, and race alongside the historic bobsled track on the Cliffside Coaster at Mt Van Hoevenberg, the longest mountain coaster in North America. In summer, the Whiteface Veterans’ Memorial Highway climbs nearly to the summit of Whiteface Mountain.
Saranac Lake
Saranac Lake trades spectacle for story. A century ago it was a world-renowned center for tuberculosis treatment, and the village is still lined with “cure cottages” whose open porches once held patients taking the mountain air. The Saranac Laboratory Museum tells that history, Robert Louis Stevenson’s winter cottage is preserved as a small museum, and the Adirondack Carousel delights kids with hand-carved Adirondack animals. In February, the Winter Carnival, held since 1897, raises an Ice Palace from blocks cut out of Lake Flower.
The edge: Lake Placid. For sheer number of headline attractions, Lake Placid wins easily. Saranac Lake’s Winter Carnival is the one event that can flip this round, so if you’re visiting in early February, call it even.
2Dining Scene
Where to Eat: Lakeside Fine Dining vs. Local Taverns
Lake Placid
Lake Placid has the deeper bench. The View at the Mirror Lake Inn is a AAA Four Diamond dining room overlooking Mirror Lake and the High Peaks, Kanu at Whiteface Lodge serves Adirondack-inspired plates in a grand lodge setting, and Main Street fills in with Smoke Signals for barbecue, Big Slide Brewery & Public House and the Lake Placid Pub & Brewery, home of Ubu Ale.
Saranac Lake
Saranac Lake eats like a town where people live year-round. Campfire Adirondack Grill at the restored Hotel Saranac channels the Great Camps in a historic 1927 hotel, Bitters & Bones pours craft drinks in a rustic-industrial tavern downtown, and the Boathouse at Saranac Waterfront Lodge puts dinner right on Lake Flower. For Italian comfort, locals head to Romano’s.
The edge: Lake Placid, narrowly. Lake Placid offers more fine-dining choice and more tables to go around. Saranac Lake feels more relaxed, and many visitors happily split the difference by eating in both.
Lake Placid is the headline act. Saranac Lake is the place you tell your friends about afterward.
Advertisement
3Recreation
Outdoors: High Peaks and Whiteface vs. Lakes and the Saranac 6er
Lake Placid
Lake Placid is the gateway to the High Peaks, the Adirondacks’ 46 summits over 4,000 feet, including Mount Marcy, the highest point in New York. Whiteface Mountain has the greatest vertical drop of any lift-served mountain in the Northeast, Mt Van Hoevenberg offers cross-country skiing, mountain biking and an indoor climbing center, and the nearly three-mile loop around Mirror Lake is the village’s favorite walk.
Saranac Lake
Saranac Lake is the paddler’s pick, with Lake Flower right downtown and the Saranac chain of lakes, rivers and campsite-dotted islands spreading west into some of the best canoe country in the Northeast. Hikers collect the Saranac Lake 6er, six peaks around the village with views out of proportion to their effort, and the Adirondack Rail Trail runs straight through town toward Lake Placid and Tupper Lake.
The edge: A draw. If you want big peaks and big skiing, base yourself in Lake Placid. If you want water and gentler summits, Saranac Lake wins. Either way, the other is 15 minutes away.
4Shopping
Shopping: Main Street Boutiques vs. Galleries and Indie Shops
Lake Placid
Lake Placid’s Main Street, running along the shore of Mirror Lake, is one of the best shopping streets in the Adirondacks, packed with outdoor outfitters, boutiques, Adirondack home goods and Olympic souvenirs, all within an easy walk of the Olympic Center.
Saranac Lake
Saranac Lake’s compact downtown mixes independent shops and outfitters with artist-run spaces such as the Adirondack Artists Guild, a co-op gallery on Main Street, and summer ArtMarkets where you can buy directly from regional makers.
The edge: Lake Placid. Lake Placid offers more stores and more variety. Saranac Lake is where you’ll find one-of-a-kind pieces made locally.
5Art & Culture
Art and Culture: Saranac Lake Runs Away With It
Lake Placid
Lake Placid’s culture leans toward performance, with the Lake Placid Center for the Arts hosting films, concerts and exhibitions, and Olympic history serving as the village’s living museum.
Saranac Lake
Saranac Lake bills itself as the arts hub of the Adirondacks, and it earns the title. Pendragon Theatre is the only year-round professional repertory theater in the Adirondacks, galleries such as NorthWind Fine Arts and the Adirondack Artists Guild show regional work, and from June through September the free Third Thursday ArtWalk turns downtown into a sidewalk festival of artists and musicians from 5 to 7:30 p.m.
The edge: Saranac Lake. This round goes clearly to Saranac Lake, a working artists’ town where the galleries, theater and ArtWalks are part of everyday life.
Plan Your Trip: Why Not Both?
The good news is that you don’t really have to choose. The 34-mile Adirondack Rail Trail, now open year-round from Lake Placid to Tupper Lake, links the two villages with about ten miles of car-free path for walking, biking and, in winter, cross-country skiing and snowmobiling. Stay in Lake Placid if you want to be in the middle of the action, or in Saranac Lake if you’d rather come home to quiet streets and lake views, and spend at least a day in the other. If your dates are flexible, the 2027 Winter Carnival runs February 5 to 14, and fall color on the trail is hard to beat.
Lake Placid vs. Saranac Lake: FAQ
Which is better, Lake Placid or Saranac Lake?
It depends on your trip. Lake Placid is better for first-time visitors who want Olympic venues, Whiteface skiing, High Peaks hiking, and a busy Main Street full of restaurants and shops. Saranac Lake is better for travelers who want a quieter, more local village with galleries, theater, lakes to paddle from downtown, and the Winter Carnival. They are only about 10 miles apart, so many visitors stay in one and spend a day in the other.
How far is Saranac Lake from Lake Placid?
Saranac Lake is about 10 miles west of Lake Placid, roughly a 15-minute drive. The two villages are also connected by about 10 miles of the Adirondack Rail Trail, which can be walked, biked or skied.
Is Saranac Lake cheaper than Lake Placid?
Often, yes. Saranac Lake generally sees less peak-season demand than Lake Placid’s Main Street, so lodging and dining can cost less, especially on busy weekends. Prices vary by season and event, so compare your specific dates.
Which is better in winter, Lake Placid or Saranac Lake?
Lake Placid is better for winter sports, with skiing at Whiteface Mountain, skating at the Olympic Center, and bobsled and cross-country skiing at Mt Van Hoevenberg. Saranac Lake is the pick in early February for its Winter Carnival, held since 1897, with its Ice Palace built from Lake Flower ice. The 2027 Winter Carnival runs February 5 to 14.
Can you bike from Lake Placid to Saranac Lake?
Yes. The Adirondack Rail Trail, a 34-mile multi-use path open year-round between Lake Placid and Tupper Lake, connects Lake Placid and Saranac Lake with about 10 miles of car-free trail for biking, walking, cross-country skiing and snowmobiling.
Is the village of Lake Placid on Lake Placid?
Mostly on Mirror Lake. The village’s Main Street runs along Mirror Lake, while the larger lake named Lake Placid lies just to the north of downtown.
How many days do you need for Lake Placid and Saranac Lake?
Three to four days works well: two days for Lake Placid’s Olympic venues, Whiteface and a High Peaks hike, and one or two days for Saranac Lake’s downtown, museums and paddling, with the Adirondack Rail Trail connecting the two.
Advertisement
